Coverage Explained

Excess Workers Compensation Insurance for Tree Service Companies

Updated 8 min read

Excess workers’ compensation insurance is for tree service companies that self-insure their workers’ comp, alone or through an approved group fund; it pays the part of a large claim, or a bad year of claims, above the retention the company keeps. A tree service with an ordinary workers’ comp policy generally does not need it, and what that company usually wants instead is an umbrella above its employer’s liability coverage.

The term causes confusion because it sounds like “extra workers’ comp.” In practice it belongs to a specific way of handling workers’ compensation that most small and mid-size tree services never use. This guide explains where it fits, who uses it, and what to ask if your company is growing toward that point.

How a Standard Workers’ Comp Policy Works

Most tree services buy a guaranteed-cost workers’ compensation policy. The insurer pays covered benefits to injured employees, and premium is based on payroll and classification. Our guide to workers’ comp class code 0106 explains how tree work is rated.

That policy has two parts. The workers’ compensation part pays the benefits your state requires. The employer’s liability part responds when an injury leads to a lawsuit against the company outside the benefit system, and it carries stated limits. Because the benefits part is not capped the way liability limits are, there is no gap for excess workers’ comp to fill on a standard policy.

Where Excess Workers’ Comp Comes In

Some employers take on the workers’ comp risk themselves instead of buying a guaranteed-cost policy. They pay claims directly, up to an amount they choose to keep, called a retention. Excess workers’ comp protects them above that retention.

Layers for a self-insured employer
Aggregate excess
Protects against a bad year when total claims run high
Specific excess
Pays above the retention on any single large claim
Retention
The company pays claims itself up to this point
Excess workers compensation insurance for tree service companies sits above the amount the company keeps for itself. No figures are shown.

Specific excess responds when a single claim exceeds the retention. For tree work, where one fall or electrical contact can produce a very large claim, this is the part that matters most.

Aggregate excess responds when the total of all claims in the policy year exceeds an agreed amount, protecting against a year with many smaller claims.

Who Self-Insures Workers’ Comp

States regulate self-insurance closely. Each state sets who can qualify, what financial strength and security deposits are required, and what reporting continues afterward. The Texas Department of Insurance describes its certified self-insurance program, and California’s Office of Self-Insurance Plans publishes an overview of self-insurance for employers. Requirements differ from state to state.

In practice, individual self-insurance is used mostly by large employers. Smaller companies that want some of the same benefits sometimes join group self-insurance funds where their state permits them, usually organized by industry. Those funds buy excess coverage for the group.

For most tree services, the more common middle ground is a large deductible workers’ comp policy, where the insurer pays claims and the employer reimburses it up to the deductible. That is not self-insurance, and it does not call for a separate excess workers’ comp policy.

Excess Workers’ Comp Versus an Umbrella

These are easy to mix up. An umbrella sits above your general liability, auto liability, and the employer’s liability part of your workers’ comp policy. It does not sit above workers’ compensation benefits. Excess workers’ comp does the opposite job, sitting above a self-insured employer’s benefit payments.

If a contract asks for “excess” coverage, read the wording. Usually the customer means umbrella limits over your liability policies. Our guide to umbrella insurance for tree trimming companies covers how those limits are chosen.

Texas Non-Subscribers Are a Different Case

Texas lets most private employers choose not to carry workers’ compensation. Those employers are non-subscribers, and they usually buy occupational accident or employer liability coverage designed for that decision. That is not excess workers’ comp. Our Texas tree service insurance page explains the subscriber decision and why most tree services stay in the system.

When to Ask About It

The question is worth raising with your agent if your company has grown to a large payroll, has years of strong safety results, and is weighing whether to take on more of its own workers’ comp risk. The answer may be a large deductible plan, a group fund, or staying with a guaranteed-cost policy. Excess workers’ comp only enters the picture once you have chosen to self-insure. Our guide to when to hire your first tree service employee covers the early-stage workers’ comp decisions most owners face first.

Employer’s Liability: The Part Most Tree Services Should Check

For a tree service with a standard workers’ comp policy, the layer that deserves attention is employer’s liability. It responds when a workplace injury leads to a lawsuit against the company outside the benefit system. Common examples:

  • A suit that comes back through a contract. An injured worker sues a general contractor or property owner, who then turns to your company under the indemnity terms of your contract.
  • Claims by family members connected to a serious injury, where the law of the state allows them.
  • Claims tied to employees working in other states, where coverage questions can arise.

Employer’s liability carries stated limits, and commercial contracts often require specific minimums. Your umbrella should list employer’s liability as underlying coverage so it can sit above it. When a contract asks for excess coverage over workers’ compensation, this is usually what the customer actually means.

Questions to Bring to Your Agent

If a customer, lender, or advisor has raised excess workers’ comp, ask your agent three things. Is the company self-insured, part of a group fund, or on a standard policy? What are the employer’s liability limits today, and do they meet your contracts? Does your umbrella list employer’s liability as underlying coverage? Those answers usually settle the question in one conversation.

Illustrative Example

This is a hypothetical, labeled example, not a real claim. A climber working for a tree service is seriously hurt on a commercial property. Workers’ compensation pays his benefits. Separately, he sues the property owner, and the owner’s attorney points to the indemnity clause in the tree service’s contract. The claim against the tree service falls under employer’s liability, and because the company’s umbrella lists employer’s liability as underlying coverage, the umbrella stands behind it. Excess workers’ comp never enters the picture, because the company was never self-insured.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is excess workers’ compensation insurance?

Excess workers’ compensation is insurance for employers that self-insure their workers’ comp, alone or through an approved group. The employer pays claims up to a retention it chooses, and the excess policy pays above that, either for a single large claim, for the total of all claims in a year, or both.

Does a tree service with a regular workers’ comp policy need excess workers’ comp?

Generally no. A standard workers’ compensation policy pays covered benefits without a cap for the statutory part of the coverage, so there is nothing for excess workers’ comp to sit above. What those companies often need instead is an umbrella that sits above the employer’s liability part of the policy.

Can a tree service company self-insure workers’ compensation?

Some states allow employers to self-insure individually or through group self-insurance funds, but each state sets its own approval rules, financial requirements, and security deposits. Individual self-insurance is generally used by larger employers with strong finances. Check your state’s workers’ compensation agency for its rules.

What is the difference between excess workers’ comp and an umbrella?

Excess workers’ comp sits above a self-insured employer’s retention for workers’ compensation benefits. An umbrella sits above general liability, auto liability, and the employer’s liability part of a workers’ comp policy. They protect different layers and are not interchangeable.

Is a Texas non-subscriber program the same as excess workers’ comp?

No. A Texas employer that opts out of the workers’ compensation system is a non-subscriber and typically buys occupational accident or employer liability coverage designed for that choice. Excess workers’ comp is for employers that stay in the system and self-insure their benefits.

The Bottom Line on Excess Workers’ Comp

Excess workers’ comp belongs to self-insured employers. If your tree service buys a regular workers’ comp policy, put your attention on employer’s liability limits and your umbrella instead. If you are large enough to weigh self-insurance or a large deductible, request a quote and we will lay out the options side by side.

Nate Jones

Nate Jones

Founder & Principal Agent, Wexford Insurance

Nate Jones is the co-founder of Wexford Insurance and TreeGuard Insurance. He works directly with tree service contractors across 48 states to build coverage that fits the way they actually work.

Ready to get properly covered?

Tell us about your tree care operation and we'll compare options across our carrier network. Quote response within 1–2 hours during business hours.

Get a Free Quote Call 317-942-0549

Independent agency · 16+ A-rated carriers · Licensed in 48 states